By that time, younger brother Chen Yujun was attracting much attention as an “emerging” artist. The years 1999 to 2005 marked a period when the Chinese art scene favored new emerging art the most. It was in this period that Chen Yujun was noticed for his excellent artistic cultivation and his mysterious and romantic Eastern-toned painting. By 2007, he had held a solo exhibition in Beijing titled Made in Jiangnan. The exhibition was something of an assessment of those “Eastern-toned” paintings. But the exhibition was not a success. The subdued response from the outside world sent him into a state of hesitation, anxiety and self-examination.
Compared to his immensely talented younger brother, Chen Yufan had a more difficult path in his early artistic career. It was not until recently that he truly established his own artistic direction—he became clearly aware that instead of the “contemporary painting” that relied on witty designs and great painting talent, he was more attracted to a simpler, purer “sense of the handmade” imprinted by the passage of time. This led him to focus his artistic experiments on a novel linguistic form: “hole punching.” Instead of painting distinctly personal brushstrokes with a refined texture, he would mechanically punch holes in cardboard or canvas like a craftsman. His new works quickly garnered recognition among his artist friends, Chen Yujun included.
But when comparing with the “post-70s art,”meaning art made by artists born in the 1970s, which was the rising trend at the time, they were both aware that their own art lacked an exciting inner energy. They did not like the excessively childish tone of “post-70s art,” but there is no doubt that naive, youthful passion was the linguistic allure that catalyzed the work of that “cohort” of artists. If that was the case, what would be the wellspring that could catalyze their own inner desires? In repeated deep discussions, they gradually came to realize it was that indescribable “emotional entanglement” that tied them to home and family. Thus, just as their individual artistic explorations were both undergoing profound internal shifts, they also decided to use collaborative installation art to process this complex, indescribable spiritual experience.
II. Mulan River
The Mulan River is a river that flows through their hometown, a small village in the famous overseas Chinese ancestral homeland of Putian, Fujian Province. The river begins on Mt. Bijia in the Daiyun Mountain Range, and crosses central and southern Putian before flowing into the Taiwan Strait. It is the largest river in Fujian, and has been called Putian's mother river. For the Chen brothers, the Mulan river is the thread that links “home” to the “outside world.” Long before the brothers were born, the “other half of the family” followed this river and left home, setting out across the South China Sea. Many years later, the brothers, as well as many other young people, floated down this river to the cities where they now reside.
The period since the end of the nineteenth century has been one of constant, dramatic transformation in Chinese society. “Reform”, “revolution”, “liberation”, “socialist reordering”, “Cultural Revolution”, “reform and opening”... Behind this string of terms are the operations of “modern civilization” on Chinese traditional society with "family” at its root—in Chinese traditional society, “family” has a special meaning. It is not like the small modern family unit, but a large clan with many branches. In the traditional concept of society, with “filial piety” at its core, the “family” tied together by blood ties is more than just the fundamental unit of the nation, but also the prototype for the entire model of the nation—a rushing wave.
Chen Yufan and Chen Yujun could be said to have grown up alongside China’s reform and opening. Though they were born in the late Cultural Revolution, they do not remember it. For them, the Cultural Revolution, and the earlier “revolution” and “resistance” are all part of the “national memory.” Their own individual memories go hand in hand with the trajectory from the abject poverty at the end of the Cultural Revolution to the constantly deepening reforms that continue today.
In their childhood memories, their “family” has been split in two, with half residing in Yuantou Village, Putian, and the other half far across the South China Sea. By the time of the brothers’ first memories, the disaster of the Cultural Revolution had ended, and in the open atmosphere of a “de-politicized” society, many traditions and practices once swept away were gradually restored. The complex public family life tied together by a proliferation of rituals—in China, families such as these Chens, who had migrated from the Central Plain to the “barbarian lands” of the south have held a particularly strong grip on the traditions and customs from their homeland—became one side of their warm childhood memories.
The other side of those childhood memories consisted of thoughts and imagination of that “other half of the family” across the seas. China has historically seen several waves of emigration due to war and other causes. In the late nineteenth century, the southeastern coast, led by Guangdong and Fujian, saw a new wave of “South Sea” emigration. Later, when overseas Chinese returned from across Asia to buy houses and land, they brought diverse exotic cultures back with them, which fused with local customs to form a unique “overseas Chinese hometown culture.” After the establishment of the People's Republic of China, ties between overseas Chinese and their homeland were cut off. For the young Chen brothers, this “other half of the family” across the seas at once consisted of the “absent ones” in family offerings, as well as the "stories” streaming from the mouths of their elders. The exotic touches scattered across their hometown lent these stories an air of legendary mystery.
Standing in contrast to the warm, romantic base tone of life from the Mulan River is the increasingly “modern” metropolitan life far from home. Studying, going to university, then working and settling in a city far from home... these are perhaps the shared experiences of many Chinese who have migrated from the countryside to the cities. As the “reform and opening” has progressed, they have experienced diverse and profound social changes: rapid economic development, constant shifts in the system, the proliferation of greed, successive waves of new social ideas. As “modern civilization” has gradually made good on its promised prosperity, it has also revealed a more sinister face. Tender, romantic childhood memories, the complex changes of the nation, and the individual drifting in the treacherous tides of society... all of these intertwine to form a tangled, unbreakable web of an “emotional complex.” The meandering Mulan River is the hub that ties it all together.
III. Installation
When the brothers were in school, “installation art” was still the purview of a small minority of “avant-garde” artists in China. But by the time they began collaborating, “installations” had already become a common sight at all manner of art exhibitions. The reason they chose the medium of installation is that they wanted to use “the substantive space of a virtual house, and the fragments of information scattered throughout... to describe a unique living space, and the alienated identity of its residents.”
The brothers’ first installation work was a “Mulan River” made from discarded newspapers, old books, gravel and other cheap materials—piles of cut up books symbolized the terrain of the scarred river, while torn cardboard and roughly processed wood composed houses wharfs and tattered boats along the banks, and meticulously carved and polished wood was used to create pavilions seeping an air of mystery. Pieces of paper scattered in the river bore drawings of people with mythical proportions. The river valley and the houses along it were all abstract and simple, and also marked with strong regional traits. For them, this Mulan River was more than just a river “imbued with religious notions of ‘fluidity’ and laden with ‘human’ and ‘geographic’ threads,” but also a river flowing with their own tender memories and carrying their profound spiritual journey.
From this point on, “homes” and “fragments of information scattered within” became the most important motifs in the Mulan River Project. Let us take Asian Circumscription–9 Square Meters, from 2009, as an example. A three cubic meter “wooden chamber” simulates a temporary living space—a space without windows or doors, empty of furniture and devoid of any traces of life. The “wooden chamber” is open, with all kinds of images affixed to the inner walls: old photographs, altered maps, hand-drawn portraits and landscapes, as well as mysterious diagrams. The monotonous grain of the wood, the pungent aroma of fresh glue, and the living memories awakened by those “information fragments” turn this “wooden chamber” into something of a mysterious “home” of disjointed time and space, a home where an erratic, unmoored experience of wandering comes together with distant recollections of the past.
In 2011, they held their first large scale installation exhibition in Beijing, titled Mulan River Project. In this exhibition, the “home” further evolved into a series of “dislocated rooms”—small, dark, empty rooms built from cardboard, small wooden rooms somewhat resembling churches perched on high stools, strange buildings surrounded by moats of wax, and black niche boxes with surreal tones of “South Seas living.” Meanwhile, beyond the "fragments of information” of the old photographs, hand-drawn images and mysterious diagrams, there also emerged a proliferation of “scattered stones”, “extended circumstances” and other information fragments with a more romantic air more suited to the situation. More importantly, this artwork not only possessed an epic sweeping narrative, it also keenly expressed a more complex spiritual conflict of “modern man” from different dimensions: nostalgia for family life, the passionate gaze on the hometown torn apart by the torrents of modernity, the silent acceptance of modern life in the “other land”—a drifting, unmoored “modern” fate—and that gloomy, anxious yet poetic sentiment of life.
IV. Goodness Flows from the Yin River
I am unsure of its significance, but in the 2017 work Mulan River | Home, the words “goodness flows from the Yin River” appear. This is a complex phrasal construct in Chinese which basically describes many branches of a family, the “goodness,” flowing out of the Yin River, which is in Henan Province, where the Chens were once an influential family. This phrase is an old heirloom this particular branch of the Chens brought with them from the Yin River in Henan Province to Putian, Fujian Province. Whether conscious or unconscious—they may have intentionally highlighted it, or it may just be a customary decorative flourish—these words allude to a more profound historical thread.
In the home’s structure, arrangements of materials, and display methods, we can see intimate links with the previous Mulan River Project artworks: wood, cardboard and cut books are still the main materials, the artwork still models a distinctive type of “house,” and we still see “information fragments” closely linked to the “home”—silhouette portraits, unexpected scenes of life, strange structures marked with both tender memories and absurd imaginings, weathered old objects, and simple implements used specifically for moving house. Furthermore, like the 2012 work Mulan River–Unsettled, this work fuses the “house” with simple shipping crates, which are both easier to ship and serve to enhance the feel of a rushed, boundless journey.
But, at first glance, the changes in Mulan River | Home are also readily apparent. The changes are first manifest in the visual atmosphere of the artwork. Though the main visual materials are still wooden boards and cut books, unlike previous artworks, which used simple composite wood and books selected at random, in Mulan River | Home, the artists carefully selected woods of different colors, textures and ages from old buildings and furniture, and paid the same attention to colors, textures and ages in their choice of books as well. These materials, with their rich arrays of colors and textures, not only lend the installation rich visual layers of antique elegance and painterliness, but the temporal information inherent in the materials themselves also gives off an air of the historical accumulation of a “home.” When these materials richly layered with visual historical information are combined with packing materials and various “single use” items as cardboard boxes, the old, tender atmosphere of “home” blends together with unmoored, drifting migration.
There is another important change in Mulan River | Home which perhaps many people have not noticed: it dilutes the flourishes of the “South Seas” while heightening the atmosphere of “home.” Though we can still see the mysterious and romantic exotic tones of these homes from the overseas Chinese ancestral homeland, what is more striking is a feel of continuing culture and a tender air of “home” conveyed through the inscribed doorway arch, the traditional folk paintings, the old doors, windows, cabinets and balconies, and the contented cat perched on the balcony.
The older history of family migration alluded to by the inscription “goodness flows from the Yin River” reveals a historical awareness that is bleaker and more profound: ceaseless flowing and migration is the true essential way of existence for the “family” and “individual life.” The “homeland” along the banks of the Mulan River—regardless of where this “homeland” comes from, what trials it has been through, or what fate it faces today—is not only a precious historical fold in the never-ending story of the “goodness flowing from the Yin River,” it is also the place where one finds true belonging. It is as the Fujianese term “cuo” encapsulates: house and home.
V. At the Confluence of History and the Future
If history is an endless string of significant moments in time, then the year 2008 will surely be one of the more important points on that string for China: the 2008 financial crisis touched off by the American mortgage market finally destroyed the “idol of modernity” that had towered high in the hearts of the Chinese since the late nineteenth century, and Chinese society began measuring this world and its own traditions through a different lens. This social awareness naturally spread to the realm of Chinese contemporary art.
If the path of the modern and contemporary art that emerged in China in the late 1970s—a constant progression from the traditional “revolutionary realism” towards Western classicalism, classic modernism, and the leading international contemporary art of the time—was originally a path of Chinese artists learning “how to be contemporary” from the West, then as the Chinese contemporary art market exploded, just as Chinese artists were broadening their horizons and bolstering their self-confidence through increasing international exchange, the question of “Chineseness” was also becoming an essential issue Chinese contemporary artists had to face. The unique social awareness that emerged in 2008 undoubtedly accelerated this shift.
Major changes in the field of art have never been purely aesthetic turns. They are recasting of art's purpose by the social ideas and unique social passions of a particular time. If the Chinese contemporary art before this amounted to a confluence of new concepts, forms and a powerful desire for emotional and spiritual liberation heavily influenced by Western contemporary art—particularly the desire to deconstruct and distance itself from various traditional values and mainstream ideology, spurred by various modern and contemporary social ideas from the West—then when these various new ideas and forms are no longer new, when the various artistic methods for deconstruction and distancing from mainstream ideology are no longer able to spark passion, what new artistic ideas and spiritual resources will come together to forge this new turn?
When the Chen brothers began creating installations, it seems they did not put much thought into this profound transformation facing Chinese contemporary art. But if we look back on the developmental trajectory of the Mulan River Project series, we can clearly see the gradual assimilation of a new artistic concept and new spiritual experience. The “installation” does not serve as some new “contemporary form” in the Mulan River Project; it is just that the “substantive spatial presence” is more suited to the expression of their inner experience. Furthermore, the Mulan River Project is not a tool for them to criticize reality or deconstruct mainstream values, but for them to probe their own complex emotional entanglements in their experience of drastic social change. In fact, the bleak and heavy historical perspective, and plain, simple yet passionate emotional attitude in Mulan River | Home have touched on the hidden spiritual dilemma of this era in a profound way.
The year 2008, when they began the Mulan River Project, represented a time of emotional catharsis for the “post-70s” generation, an expression of a unique youthful experience, of “brutal youth” and the “anime generation.” A decade later, as those artists face increasingly serious tests, the art of the Chen brothers has met with wider recognition and affirmation. Tracing the cause of this, it is not only because the Mulan River Project touched on the nostalgia of an era, but more importantly because their art has come to embody the relationship between art and new social ideas and passions with ever greater clarity. The elegant and profound visual feel of the artworks has come to take on more of a Chinese air, and the epic proportions of the artworks, with their bleak, heavy and yet still romantic emotional bearing, are bringing greater clarity to the increasingly mature artistic character of the “post-70s artists.”
Aug 8 2017